Rethinking Budgeting Forum

 View Only
  • 1.  Budgeting Process Questions

    Posted Feb 20, 2025 05:48 PM

    What is your current budgeting process? How do you engage stakeholders, set priorities, and address challenges along the way?



    ------------------------------
    Timothy Martin
    Senior Manager for Marketing & Digital Experiences
    GFOA
    ------------------------------


  • 2.  RE: Budgeting Process Questions

    Posted Feb 21, 2025 10:22 AM

    Our Budget Process is mostly done in Excel and copies the prior years workpapers and then roll forward to do again.  We need a better all encompassing approach.  I am hoping to find some answers here.  

    I have been trying to split out the staffing expectations with a 10 year projection.  Also, the Capital Projects with a 10 year projection.  When these two are done, they get wound up into the full operating budget for the year.  We just developed a Finance Committe with two councilmembers participating.  We are hoping for some feedback to make these documents more user friendly.



    ------------------------------
    Sharon Wright
    Finance Director
    City of North Branch
    North Branch MN
    ------------------------------



  • 3.  RE: Budgeting Process Questions

    Posted Feb 21, 2025 11:40 AM

    Ours is basically the same as Sharon describes - done in Excel and copy the "master" file from one year to the next and then drop in the individual department sheets prepared by Department Heads. The manager and I do revenues with some departmental input.  We do hold mini workshops with our board and each department head to allow him/her to make a case for requests and future planning.  The manager works through the master file as we have these to mark "yes" or "no" to items the board seems to approve/disapprove.  The budget notebooks are then put together and we have budget workshops to allow the board to further discuss and make what is normally their final decision.  Of course, we all know nothing is final until the actual vote at a regular meeting and not even then because we can amend.  The citizens are not involved beyond the required public hearing.



    ------------------------------
    Susan O'Brien
    Director of Finance & Personnel
    City of King
    King NC
    ------------------------------



  • 4.  RE: Budgeting Process Questions

    Posted Feb 28, 2025 10:11 AM

    Thanks for the insight Sharon and Susan! I would also recommend checking various research reports in the "how to budget" section of our Rethinking Budgeting Reports page. Also, you may find our new research report Target-Based Budgeting very helpful. 



    ------------------------------
    Timothy Martin
    Senior Manager for Digital Experiences
    GFOA - Research and Consulting
    Chicago IL
    ------------------------------



  • 5.  RE: Budgeting Process Questions

    Posted Mar 07, 2025 11:26 AM

    Our process is very similar to Susan's process.  We do budget Capital on a 20-year planning basis & Personnel on a 5-year basis.  We are trying to implement a different approach this year with more emphasis placed on Strategic Goals but not all areas of the County embrace the Strategic Goals set by our Board so it's being met with some resistance.



    ------------------------------
    Jennifer Ludwick
    Executive Finance Director
    Allegan County
    Allegan MI
    ------------------------------